1 - Debating students-Holes

LitOn·

Literature

Preview

At a Glance

Grade Level5th Grade

SubjectLiterature

Original Prompt

Debate: Should the Poppers Have Kept the Penguins as Pets?after reading 'Mr. Popper's Penguins' pro vs. con

This resource provides a structured approach for students to engage in critical thinking and debate regarding the character of Piper from the novel 'Al Capone Does My Shirts.' It outlines a learning objective focused on evaluating Piper as either a villain or a victim of her circumstances within the context of the Great Depression. The resource includes team assignments for debate, guiding questions, argument points, and text evidence to support claims from both perspectives. By engaging in this debate, students will analyze Piper's actions, the influence of her environment, and the impact of societal pressures during the 1930s, fostering a deeper understanding of the character's motivations and complexities.