Argumentative Writing: Dusty the Cat

Katie·

Writing

Preview

At a Glance

Grade Level5th Grade

SubjectWriting

Original Prompt

Create a comprehensive argumentative writing assessment package that develops students' ability to analyze informational texts, construct evidence-based arguments, and communicate persuasively in academic writing. The prompt should challenge students to take a clear position on a debatable issue presented in the text while demonstrating critical thinking through careful evaluation of evidence and counterarguments. Include scaffolding tools that guide students through the complete writing process...

This resource focuses on teaching students how to construct a clear, evidence-based argument using the Hamburger Method. The main task revolves around the story of Dusty, a cat known for stealing items from neighbors, prompting students to debate whether his actions are acceptable. The material provides detailed instructions and a structured graphic organizer to help students write an argumentative essay. Components include stating a position, providing reasons supported by text evidence, addressing counterarguments, and concluding effectively. Success criteria ensure students know what elements to include in their writing, fostering critical thinking and writing skills.