Original Prompt6th Grade Social Studies • 10-Day NTI Historical Inquiry
DAY 7
Athens vs. Sparta
Evidence Is Not Enough — Explain Your Reasoning
Name: __________________________________
Date: __________________
LEARNING INTENTION
We are learning to connect evidence to reasoning so that we can defend a judgment about two different societies.
SUCCESS CRITERIA
☐ I can establish a criterion for comparison.
☐ I can select relevant evidence.
☐ I can explain HOW evidence supports my claim.
☐ I can acknowle...
This learning resource focuses on constructing a historical argument centered on the contributions of two prominent city-states in Ancient Greece: Athens and Sparta. Students will explore the differences between Athenian democracy and Spartan militarism, analyzing key sources that outline cultural, political, and social aspects of both city-states. The resource encourages critical thinking by having students define what makes a contribution significant, select evidence to support their claims, and articulate reasoning that connects their evidence to their argument. Students will also engage with opposing viewpoints on both city-states to further enrich their understanding and perspective.