This resource focuses on exploring the legal frameworks depicted in the epic poem Beowulf, particularly the concepts of 'Wergild' (man-price) and 'Feud' mechanics. Students engage in critical analysis of the characters Grendel and Grendel's Mother, examining the legitimacy of their actions through the lens of Anglo-Saxon law. The learning objectives encourage students to synthesize peer dialogue with their legal reasoning, evaluate how interpretations of justice evolve through discussion, and apply ancient legal concepts to contemporary issues. The exercise emphasizes metacognition by having students reflect on their initial positions and how peer arguments shape their understanding of morality and law within the narrative context of Beowulf. Additionally, it challenges students to draw parallels between historical and modern legal frameworks for resolving conflicts.