Group Scenario Discussion

Shawn·

Theology

Preview

At a Glance

SubjectTheology

This resource delves into the Problem of Evil through an analysis of the 'Inconsistent Triad', which outlines the tension between God's omnipotence, omnibenevolence, and the existence of evil. Students will examine various theodicies including Augustinian, Soul-Making, Free Will Defense, and Protest Theodicy to understand how these frameworks attempt to reconcile the coexistence of God and suffering. The learning objective encourages critical thinking as students assess different theological explanations for suffering, using structured group roles such as facilitator, theologian, and skeptic. Additionally, the resource includes ethical scenarios for group analysis, prompting discussion on the implications of suffering and the effectiveness of these theodicies, along with a CER (Claim, Evidence, Reasoning) framework for structuring arguments and a metacognitive reflection on their reasoning.