Original Promptlesson plan with introduction steps and talking points for this discussion activity- making it as student led as possible so teacher can sit back
This resource outlines a Socratic seminar centered around a high-stakes moral dilemma involving 28 individuals and 15 spots in a lifeboat. Participants take on the role of a final crew member tasked with guiding the group to safety through critical analysis and discussions on ethical criteria for determining who should survive. The seminar encourages respectful disagreement, active listening, and the examination of factors like health, age, moral failings, and personal resilience in making difficult decisions regarding societal contribution versus human worth. Through phases of individual reflection and group dynamics, participants confront biases, navigate conflicting moral values, and ultimately decide on the passengers who will be prioritized for survival, concluding with a reflective exit ticket to process the implications of their choices.