Debunk the Myths! The True Story of Thanksgiving

Thanksgiving is more than turkey and football! This engaging reading comprehension worksheet challenges students to dig beneath the surface of the traditional Thanksgiving narrative. Explore the complexities of the "First Thanksgiving" with a focus on historical accuracy and critical thinking.

What's Included:

• A captivating reading passage that explores:
  • The Pilgrims' dependence on the Wampanoag people for survival
  • The "First Thanksgiving" as a celebration but not a lasting peace treaty
  • The importance of understanding historical context
• A primary source analysis activity with an excerpt from Edward Winslow's journal
• Multiple choice, true/false, fill-in-the-blank, and short answer questions to assess reading comprehension, critical thinking, and analysis skills
• A detailed answer key to save you time and ensure accurate grading

Learning Objectives:

• Students will be able to identify the challenges faced by the Pilgrims in Plymouth.
• Students will distinguish between fact and fiction in the traditional Thanksgiving story.
• Students will analyze the significance of the "First Thanksgiving" within the broader context of Wampanoag-Pilgrim relations.
• Students will develop critical thinking skills by examining primary source evidence.

Common Core Standards Addressed:

• RI.5.1: Quote accurately from a text when explaining what the text says explicitly and when drawing inferences from the text.
• RI.5.2: Determine the central ideas or author's purpose of a text and explain how it is supported by key details.
• RI.5.3: Explain the relationships or connections between ideas or events in a text.
• RI.5.7: Draw information from all features of a text (e.g., title, headings, illustrations, diagrams) when reading to learn or perform a task.

Content Discussion Points:

• How did the Wampanoag people's help contribute to the Pilgrims' survival?
• What does the primary source excerpt reveal about the preparations for the gathering?
• Why is it important to move beyond a romanticized version of Thanksgiving?
• How can understanding the complexities of Thanksgiving contribute to a more inclusive celebration?

Ready to unlock your students' critical thinking potential? Explore my store for a treasure trove of reading comprehensions that tackle diverse themes and inspire insightful discussions. From the intricacies of the Civil War to the marvels of scientific discovery, there's something for every classroom!

Support a fellow educator and get rewarded! Purchase this resource, leave a review, and earn TeachShare credits you can use on any product on the platform. Your feedback helps others and benefits you too!